Alastair sim as scrooge adapted from charles dickens a christmas carol. What is the difference in the hell scene for the book a. Henry vernon esmond portrays scrooge, and the lively film efficiently hits all of the storys high points. The film was ed and released in the united states under the title a christmas carol, but released in great britain as scrooge.
A christmas carol, the popular 1843 novella by charles dickens 18121870, is one of the. At this point the story turns into the animated version and dickens explains that the mouse, na. She is cynical, selfish, and generally treats her employees with cold contempt. It stars alastair sim as ebenezer scrooge, and was produced and directed by brian desmond hurst, with a screenplay by noel langley. A christmas carol fairy tales and bedtime stories for kids in english. Quotes on the tv movie this a christmas carol is distinctive and enduring enough that one tends to forget it was originally made for television. Its inarguably the best version of dickens immortal tale of greed and redemption ever to be captured on film. I love a muppet christmas carol, and i like the george c. A christmas carol comparison by bethany stafford on prezi. Since its publication, the book has been adapted numerous times for theater, opera, television, and film. While use of movies in the classroom can be controversial.
The movie is a 2001 british live actionanimated film based on charles dickenss 1843 classic novella a christmas carol. A christmas carol is a 1999 britishamerican madefortelevision film adaptation of charles dickens famous 1843 novella a christmas carol that was first televised december 5, 1999 on tnt. The miser scrooge passes down a london street the morning before christmas, on his way to his counting house. Scrooge released as a christmas carol in the united states is a 1951 british christmas fantasy drama film and an adaptation of charles dickens a christmas carol 1843. When i bought it i was intrigued to finally watch the story with a twist of ghostly horror. It is the story of ebenezer scrooge, a greedy miser who hates christmas, but is transformed into a caring, kindly person through the visitations of four ghosts. There have been several great renditions of charles dickens a christmas carol, the wellknown story about an old grump who, with the help of three visiting spirits on christmas eve, finds the true meaning of being rich. A christmas carol 1938 cast and crew crotchety miser ebenezer scrooge reginald owen hates christmas and mistreats his longsuffering employee, devoted family man bob cratchit gene lockhart. This animated version of charles dickens classic story christmas carol adds some new touches, but primarily follows the traditional tale of the miserly and cruel ebenezer scrooge being confronted. A christmas carol written by charles dickens was published as a novella on december 19th of 1843.
This version has been recorded by bing crosby, ed ames, frank sinatra, kate smith, and many others. This story strongly follows the dickens christmas carol format. Stevenuniverseisawesome all time favorite xmas movie manlypants well its a good movie but i dont think it was the best christmas carol apdition it could be one of but it did get a little stale at some scenes but i think michael kane does a good scrooge impression and the muppets are very likeable and enjoyable here i mean their fun. It is an adaptation of the charles dickens story of the same. So much is he detested that no one speaks to him until a beggar approaches, asks for alms, and is angrily stricken to the ground. In an interview with the hollywood reporter in 1988 promoting the films release on home video, actress june lockhart admitted that, despite being an mgm production, it was a b.
Sim appeared to embody exactly the character that dickens created. Scrooge renamed a christmas carol when it was released in america is widely considered the definitive cinema version of dickens novel. The many adaptations of charles dickens a christmas carol ranked from worst to best, from a 1901 silent film to the 2009 computergenerated feature. The film is directed by clive donner, who had been an editor of the 1951 film scrooge, and stars george c. In my near 70 years, i have seen many movie versions of this book. With guy pearce, andy serkis, stephen graham, joe alwyn. The idea of having a dark take was, to me, a great idea. The movie 2001, an animated version produced by illuminated films christmas carol, ltdthe. The right to be happy this 1916 silent movie was the first full length film version of a christmas carol, starring rupert julian in the scrooge role.
This version of a christmas carol is definitely a dark version of the beloved story. The man who invented christmas needed to accomplish two tasks. In 1988, mgmua home video and turner entertainment released a christmas carol on vhs celebrating its 50th anniversary, for the first time in a colorized version. There are many versions of the movie a christmas carol, which is based on charles dickens 1843 novel of the same name. Since the late 1990s, it has been broadcast on turner classic movies, airing several times during december. Consequently, i appreciated the way zemeckis didnt simply turn it into just another serving of christmas comfort food.
A christmas carol is a 1984 britishamerican madefortelevision film adaptation of charles dickens famous 1843 novella of the same name. As he begins his story of ghosts a woman in the audience screams because she has seen a mouse and dickens points out that this is appropriate since his story begins with a mouse. It was filmed in the historic medieval county town of shrewsbury in shropshire. This version differs from others, in that scrooge is.
It was directed by david jones and stars patrick stewart as ebenezer scrooge and richard e. It read like a muppets cristmas carol a movie i love. Does anyone know if this book is available in an audible version anywhere. The classic work has been dramatised and adapted countless times for virtually every medium and performance. A look at the various film adaptations of charles dickens a christmas carol.
Just like the charles dickens christmas carol namesake, this book sends a clear i was first attracted. A christmas carol film adaptations best and worst movie. A christmas carol 1951 cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. A christmas carol christmas pudding food in literature english christmas. Charles dickens is the original author of a christmas carol, which he wrote as a novel in 1843. A christmas carol tv short 1971 company credits imdb. The 1951 adaptation of charles dickens timeless classic is perhaps the most faithful film version and alastair sims performance as scrooge is not to be.
Includes evaluation of the movie vs book pairing with several options. The 10 best versions ever made according to imdb nearly 200 years later, charles dickens a christmas carol is one of the most beloved stories of all time and often adapted for film and television. A christmas carol, the popular 1843 novella by charles dickens 18121870, is one of the british authors bestknown works. Get an answer for what is the difference in the hell scene for the book a christmas carol and the movie scrooge 1970. Aided by noel langleys the wizard of oz insightful script and some truly phenomenal performances, director brian desmond hurst gave us a grand christmas present with this film. A christmas carol the best christmas carol movie is.
Being a history of a christmas carol on film by richard jones. Charles dickens a christmas carol makes for a great party theme these dickens. This activity bundle gives you several choices for comparing the text of a christmas carol by charles dickens with some or all of one of the movie or play versions. With alastair sim, jack warner, kathleen harrison, mervyn johns. Tell the story of how charles dickens created the beloved classic a christmas carol, and in turn illustrate how the story. The story concerns the overly prudent businessman ebeneezer scrooge sim, who becomes a saint overnight. Murakami, the film features the voices of numerous actors including simon callow, kate winslet who also sang the films theme what if, kates sister beth winslet, and nicolas cage. Bbc learning english dramas from bbc learning english. A christmas carol film adaptations best and worst movie versions. Smoking bishop is traditionally a version of mulled wine made with port. This is arguably the movie version of a christmas carol to which all.
A christmas carol adaptations ranked from worst to best. The film was produced after patrick stewart performed a series of successful one man shows. The 6 best a christmas carol movie adaptations ever, ranked. A spirit appears and tells the miser that the beggar will again appear that night.
Scott did an excellent version for tv in 1984, and albert finney played ebenezer scrooge in a 1970 movie musical. Scott version is the one i prefer and that i always used with my 7th grade english classes, but the muppet version is also welldone, with humor that appeals to adults as well as kids. In recent weeks ghosts, dozens maybe even thousands of them, have been appearing in my front room. I have, you see, been watching the many film versions there have been of the charles dickens classic in an endeavour to find the best movie adaptation of a christmas carol every year, around early december, i prepare myself for. A christmas carol 1951 rotten tomatoes movie trailers. The 1951 version of charles dickens classic tale was first released as scrooge in the uk, but the american markets changed the title to a. She has been coached by her late aunt marla dinah manoff to behave this way.
First off, let me say that i liked the movie a lot. It was an instant success and has been popularized and has never been out of print. A christmas carol another silent movie version from the united kingdom, this 1923 film stars russell. Alastair sim breathes depth and complexity into scrooge, showing us a man bewildered at times by his.
However, this christmas eve he will be visited by three spirits who will show him the errors of his ways. One of the most recent film adaptations of a christmas carol is walt disney pictures 3d version. The british governments answer to this escalating crisis was the poor. The story that dickens wrote in 1838 remains timeless, and if its supercharged here with scrooge swooping the london streets as freely as superman, well, once you let ghosts into a. Worlds leading producer of aluminum, thats aluminium for english readers and viewers before the opening. One of the best screen adaptations of charles dickens a christmas carol. The book just had the narrator in th ebeginning of each seen. He shouts and bah humbugs until, as the story always goes, he returns home on christmas eve to. The supporting cast is also superb with the standouts being kathleen harrison as mrs. Carol cartman tori spelling is a conceited sensationalist talk show host. Disneys a christmas carol is a 2009 american 3d computer animated motioncapture fantasy film written and directed by robert zemeckis. Scott version as well, but the 1951 film with alastair sim is the definitive one for me. On christmas eve, hours before her talk show is set to go on the air, she is haunted by her aunt maria who is wrapped in golden chains who warns her of the.
The man who invented christmas the creation of dickens classic 01 dec 2017 by joe ursell in film features. Welcome to yify subtitles, a subtitles site for all movies. The musical 1992, a british stage musical adapted from the 1970 film and starring anthony newley. Disneys a christmas carol by robert zemeckis and charles dickens, of course is an exhilarating visual experience and proves for the third time hes one of the few directors who knows what hes doing with 3d. The film begins with a liveaction sequence set in boston in 1857, the site of a live reading by renowned novelist dickens. The third of three spirits episode 170120 20 jan 2017 ebenezer scrooge is getting used to the company of ghosts, but heres one he doesnt expect.
It has since been adapted into a movie nearly 50 times, starting all the way back in 1901. The biggest difference between the book and the muppet version of a christmas carol was that the movie had a narrator through the whole show. Johnny marks, known for his song rudolph the rednosed reindeer, set longfellows poem to music in 1956. As a lover of dickens story, ive seen more than my share of christmas carol adaptations in my time, both good and bad. A television adaptation of charles dickens classic christmas tale of the miser ebenezer scrooge.
It was written at a time when people were beginning to sing carols and make celebrate christmas with parties. We look at how the man who invented christmas presents a different side to charles dickens and demonstrates the influence of a christmas carol to this day. During the movie the narrator would be involed during the whole show. A christmas carol is one of the most compelling, insightful, and eerie stories ever written by charles dickens and when youre talking about the man who wrote oliver twist, great expectations. In disneys a christmas carol ebenezer scrooge is at his scroogiest. Ebenezer scrooge, a curmudgeonly, miserly businessman, has no time for sentimentality and largely views christmas as a waste of time. With original illustrations in full color hardcover at. I have, you see, been watching the many film versions there have been of the charles dickens classic in an endeavour to find the best movie adaptation of a christmas carol. The best dance number, groucho marx tribute, cartoon adult directed innuendos and ghost of christmas future parody ever made.
1550 269 1114 1631 831 726 772 338 1109 896 202 9 194 545 419 785 101 240 736 1194 1020 730 1256 800 838 1266 1410 328 1151 655 1454 1405 1205 491 1488 1477 126